Rejecting god leads to the absurd situation of not being able to know if everything you think is real isnt actually a dream, or an illusion. Happiness and the meaning of life home university of. There is no objective meaning to life without god duration. Absurdity ought to be understood in a dichotomous manner. Like prisoners condemned to death, we await our unavoidable execution.
M ost people feel on occasion that life is absurd, and some. The absurdity of life with or without god can there be ultimate meaning, value or purpose in life without god and immortality. Without god the universe is a result of a cosmic accident, a chance explosion. Other animals have instincts to guide them, but man has learned to ask questions. This line of thinking is laid out most clearly in william lane craigs essay the absurdity of life without god. In a famous 1971 paper, the absurd, thomas nagel argues that lifes absurdity has nothing to do with its length. He also explains life without god mankind and the world we live in is meaningless and is doomed to death. I use the term god with an upper case g to refer specifically to the god of christianity, along with its various attributes, such as omnipotence, omniscience and so forth. The absurdity of life without god christian library. Judging whether life is or is not worth living amounts to answering the fundamental question of philosophy. In your work on the subject, you seem to put forth. The absurdity of life without god the veritas forum.
The absurdity of life without god william lane craig duration. He holds out hope, even to the hostile cancerstricken atheist, until the very last breath of life is. Man is alienated from himself, from other persons, and from god, and as a result man has been burdened with absurdity. Craig reveals the deadends that modern scholars have run into when trying to make sense of life without god and shows that the god of the bible has provided what humans have been seeking all along. All the rest whether or not the world has three dimensions, whether the mind has nine or twelve categoriescomes afterwards. The absurdity of life without god william lane craig start. And it is often said that we of the modern age lack a proper sense of reverence for that mystery. The absurd is not the absurd or absurdities without any distinction wherefore.
It would have no meaning without god or an afterlife. Jul 24, 2017 camus who years earlier had asserted that there is no love of life without despair of life answers. The solution to this absurdity is accepting revelation from god who tells us in the bible that he is real, that he cannot lie hebrews 6. We are alone, without god and without any transcendent values to give meaning and purpose to our lives. Hitlers values are just as good as those of a saint. Perhaps there are human purposes, purposes to be found in life, and we can and do have them even in a godless world, but without god there can be no one. Wittgenstein states that the desire to say something about the ultimate meaning of life is a document of tendency in the human mind which i personally cannot help respecting deeply and i would not for my life ridicule it. The objective absurdity is the metanarratives of life.
I the thought is, if this question had an answer, then it would give meaning to the various pieces of your life e. Jan, 2018 the absurdity of life without god discussion in christianity and world religion started by imalllikeokwaitwat, jan, 2018. Hey gang, it has been a while since i presented but i think i have a good one lined up for you. Read article and write a detailed response to these specific questions in essay format. In craigs argument, he explains that life without god is absurd. He was haunted by this question of whether suicide could be the only rational response to the. Albert camus on the three antidotes to the absurdity of life. The forums in the christian congregations category are now open only to christian members.
The absurdity of life without god christian forums. Related resources for the absurdity of life without god on. Since i personally dont care for pdf if a good html source is. Christianity and the problem of popular culture notes. This line of thinking is laid out most clearly in william lane craigs essay the absurdity of life. The primary motive of this conclusion is the idea that, without god, there is no immortality. I know it is getting close to the holidays and many of you are crazy busy and might not be able to make it but based on the interest and how much we cover this. He is the only creature in the universe who asks, why. Nov 23, 2008 the absurdity of life without god and immortality. Apathy, atheism, and the absurdity of life without god.
Our lives are mere instants even on a geological time scale, let alone a cosmic one. He wrote about his battle in a recent vanity fair article. He goes on to say that without the existence of god mans life becomes absurd. Craig explains that mankind has no purpose, no value in life without god. Without god the universe is the result of a cosmic accident, a chance explosion. Christian apologists have argued that life is absurd without the christian god. The absurdity of life without god some people dismiss god far too quickly and do not understand that it is impossible to make sense of human experience and the world without reference to an all powerful creator. But more than that, even if life did not end in death, without god life would still be without purpose. Fernandes looks at the competing worldviews and shows the absurdity of life without god.
Every religious believer, and every nonbeliever, should read this powerful presentation of the absurdity of life without god. Deciding whether or not life is worth living is to answer the fundamental question in philosophy. Because of this ultimate endwithout immortality and godlife is ultimately meaningless, valueless, and purposeless, objectively speaking. Christopher hitchens tries to debate william lane craig, instantly regrets it. Man is left with nothing but speculation and emptiness.
Absurdity and the meaning of life university of notre dame. A major turning point in my life happened when i was 18 and i experienced gods presence in a powerful way during a church service. The astronaut has two vials, one filled with a deadly poison, and the other with a. If however your point is actually without a god your life can. Why i must believe in god because i am terrifi ed of dying william lane craig why on atheism life has no ultimate meaning, value, or purpose, and why this view is unlivable. This particular topic, the absurdity of life without god, starts from the very beginning. The absurdity of life without god william lane craigs.
The absurdity of life without god 1 of 3 by william lane. The absurdity of life without god by william lane craig, a lecture given at biola university on 5 march, 2002. For if there is no god, then mans life becomes absurd. Craig, though i respect you as one of todays most rational christian thinkers, i passionately disagree with your assertion that life without god is absurd. The veritas forum invites students and faculty to ask lifes hardest questions. The absurdity of life without god william lane craig. William lane craig on the absurdity of life without god michael hauskeller is life meaningless without god. Perhaps then, apathy or apatheism is not something that can be changed directly, i. William lane craig provides a devastating existential ethical refutation of atheism in an article i posted entitled, the absurdity of life without god. A major turning point in my life happened when i was 18 and i experienced god s presence in a powerful way during a church service.
Redemption is possible because there really is a redeemer. Everyone needs to create his own god in order to face the oblivion of death. Mccloskey refers to the arguments as proofs and often implies that they cant definitively establish the case for god, so therefore they should be abandoned. So not only is the life of each individual person doomed. Life is absurd, they claim, because death robs us of a future and puts an end to all our projects, desires, and aspirations. Jan 12, 2018 the absurdity of life without god william lane craig duration. The arguments you proffer to support this are quite superficial, and it is unfortunate that intelligent philosophers like yourself have fallen prey to accepting these monstrosities. Atheism, meaning, and the absurdity of it all psychology today. The absurdity of life without god 1 of 3 by william lane craig. Dec 16, 2008 the absurdity of life without god by william lane craig, a lecture given at biola university on 5 march, 2002 painstakingly transcribed from tape this a topic that is most serious and somber. Craig the absurdity of life without god by william lane. For the reasonable person, reflection on the absurdity of life without god should be enough to extinguish any remaining apathy regarding the question of gods existence. To put it simply, william lane craig demolishes any shred of a claim that atheism can offer any ultimate meaning, any ultimate value, or any ultimate purpose whatsoever.
One of the apologetic questions that contemporary christian theology must treat in its doctrine of man is what has been called the human predicament, that is to say, the significance of human life in a posttheistic universe. Christian members please remember to read the statement of purpose threads for each forum within christian congregations before posting in the forum. The meaning of life i the question of the meaning of life is the question \what is the ultimate justi cation of the signi cance of my life. Now some at this point will bite the bullet and embrace the despair that their life has no ultimate value without god and that for them that serves to allow such freedom in choosing ones own way that theyd say its a far happier way to live in the end as long as you. The absurd is that the eternal truth has come into existence in time, that god has come into. With or without coffee, life is a profound mystery. The world, the earth itself becomes god, or perhaps carl sagans cosmos replaces god. It is largely geared towards individuals who view meaning, value, and morality as being wholly independent of a divine being. The absurdity of life without god related resources from. Moreover, there are no objective standards of right and wrong. Absurdity and suicide there is but one truly serious philosophical problem, and that is suicide. Using the argument presented by william lane craig in the. Pdf william lane craig on the absurdity of life without.
For man and the universe would then be mere accidents of chance thrust into existence for no reason. Atheism fails absurdity of life without god can be shown. If young people buy hitchens atheism, theyll not only lose god, but themselves. Apr 11, 2001 the veritas forum invites students and faculty to ask life s hardest questions. The article, the absurdity of life without god by william craig. I grew up going to church from the age of about 5 after my mum became a christian, and when i was i gave my life to jesus at a church youth camp. Life without god popular writings reasonable faith. My contention is that craig not only fails to establish his conclusion, but fails to advance any cogent or coherent argument at all. He says, there is only one really serious philosophical problem, and that is suicide. Craig uses the example of a science fiction book he read as a child where an astronaut is marooned on a barren planet.
If there is no god, then man and the universe are doomed. Craig argues that if life ends at the grave, it would make no difference whether a person was good or bad. The absurdity of life without god common sense atheism. Accepting the absurdity of everything around us is one step, a necessary experience. T heistic philosophers and theologians have historically argued that life in an atheistic universe is devoid of meaning, value, or any reason for hope.
Camus who years earlier had asserted that there is no love of life without despair of life answers. Jul 08, 2017 life is absurd, they claim, because death robs us of a future and puts an end to all our projects, desires, and aspirations. If a short life is absurd, he says, a longer life would be even more absurd. What would be the point of living if you thought that life was absurd, that it could never have meaning. This is precisely the question that camus asks in his famous work, the myth of sisyphus. Apr 24, 2018 for the reasonable person, reflection on the absurdity of life without god should be enough to extinguish any remaining apathy regarding the question of gods existence. Suppose i said, our ultimate purpose in life is to make co 2 for gods plants and trees, something were clearly good at. God as meaningprovider is replaced with creative human beings as meaningproviders. Dec, 2014 this piece is a critique of william lane craigs piece the absurdity of life without god, in which he attempts to argue that under an atheistic worldview life has no ultimate meaning, value, or purpose. William lane craig argues that, if there is no god, then life itself lacks meaning, value, and purpose. Internationally renowned theologian and apologist william lane craig invites us to imagine a world without god. The article the absurdity of life without god by william.
Pdf many major historical figures in philosophy have provided an answer. The sense that life as a whole is absurd arises when we perceive, perhaps dimly, an inflated pretension or aspiration which is inseparable from the continuation of human life and which makes its absurdity inescapable, short of escape from life itself. Let us call this the meaningless sense of absurdity. The absurdity of life without god the christian apologetics. It derives from the latin absurdum meaning out of tune, hence irrational. No doubt absurd is used in this sense when, for example, religious apologists speak of the absurdity of human existence without god.
With a commitment to courageous discourse we put the historic christian faith in dialogue with other beliefs and invite participants from all backgrounds to pursue truth together. William craigs the absurdity of life without god presents a great work that supports this argument. This piece is a critique of william lane craigs piece the absurdity of life without god, in which he attempts to argue that under an atheistic worldview life has no ultimate meaning, value, or purpose. The absurdity of life without god the veritas forum the. William lane craig gives a lecture on whether life has meaning without god. The absurdity of life without god by william lane craig, a lecture given at biola university on 5 march, 2002 painstakingly transcribed from tape this a topic that is most serious and somber.
An absurdity is a thing that is extremely unreasonable, so as to be foolish or not taken seriously, or the state of being so. Wlclec010a format audio cd length in minutes 96 speaker william lane craig, ph. In philosophy, the absurd refers to the conflict between the human tendency to seek inherent. What would you say about this i light of foremans comments in his approaching the. The absurdity of life without god reasonable faith.
He was haunted by this question of whether suicide could be the only rational response to the absurdity of life. Now it might also be suggested that to say that something is absurd it simply to say that it is meaningless. If god does not exist, then both man and the universe are inevitably doomed to death. The absurdity of life without god one of the apologetic questions that contemporary christian theology must treat in its doctrine of man is what has been called the human predicament, that is to say, the significance of human life in a posttheistic universe.
The absurdity of life without god by william lane craig, a lecture given at biola. Why i must believe in god because i am terrified of dying. Pdf william lane craig on the absurdity of life without god. For man and the universe would then be simple accidents of chance, thrust into existence for no reason. Fernandes examines these questions and points out that apart from the revelation of god to provide a firm foundation and grounding for human existence noting truly makes sense. The absurdity of life without god and immortality if there is no god, then man and the universe are doomed. The absurdity of life without god william lane craig christian philosophy3,14. You cant fathom how such a purpose makes our lives ultimately significant, but trust me. Absurdity is experienced subjectively, such that the individual experiences it in an autonomous manner. In your work on the subject, you seem to put forth two basic contentions, 1 that life without god is devoid of ultimate meaning, purpose, and value and 2 that theism can provide ultimate meaning, purpose, and value.
1140 954 563 740 320 377 1046 556 270 876 1335 996 91 392 94 178 169 103 337 911 515 227 1302 721 1259 500 1186 1173 821 332 570